As Fred Davie, an administrator at Union Theological Seminary, noted, Rabbi Sharon Kleinbaum’s departure from Congregation Beth Simchat Torah (CBST) has left many wondering what comes next for this beloved synagogue and its community. For 15 years, Kleinbaum served as the chief rabbi of CBST, a progressive Jewish congregation that has been a beacon of inclusivity and acceptance.
Kleinbaum’s decision to step down was not taken lightly; she had already announced her plans to leave last year. However, it wasn’t until Yom Kippur services in September that the news sank in for many members. The sold-out event featuring New York Attorney General Letitia James as a keynote speaker only added to the sense of loss and uncertainty.
As Kleinbaum reflected on her time at CBST, she drew parallels between the congregation’s experiences during the AIDS crisis and those faced during COVID-19. Both periods required extraordinary measures to cope with isolation, loneliness, and fear – “muscle memory” that has become second nature for many in this community.
While a new chief rabbi will take over on July 1st, Jason Klein (no relation), it’s clear that Kleinbaum is irreplaceable. Her legacy extends far beyond her leadership; she created a space where people could be their authentic selves without fear of judgment or rejection. This sacred space has been transformed into an oasis for those seeking refuge from the outside world.
As Hibsher, a member of CBST, astutely observed: “There’s a landscape of wonderful progressive synagogues throughout Manhattan… So part of the question for the congregation will be: Is there still a need for an LGBT synagogue in 2024? I think there is.” Kleinbaum’s departure has left many wondering if this unique space can continue to thrive without her at its helm.
In the end, it’s not just about replacing one leader with another; it’s about preserving the essence of CBST – a community that has been shaped by Kleinbaum’s unwavering commitment to inclusivity and acceptance. As James so eloquently put it: “This space… where we can be safe… where we can be free.”